Comparison of Concurrent Chemoradiotherapy or Radiotherapy alone after
Induction Chemotherapy for Hypopharyngeal Cancer
Abstract
Objectives Our study aimed to compare the efficacy and toxicity of
induction chemotherapy (IC) followed by concurrent chemoradiotherapy
(CCRT) or radiotherapy (RT) alone in patients with locally advanced
hypopharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (HPSCC). Design: Cohort
Retrospective study Settings: Data of HPSCC patients collected from 2008
to 2020 Participants: 83 HPSCC patients Main outcomes measures: 83
patients with HPSCC in our center, who received IC followed by either
CCRT or RT alone according to multidisciplinary team (MDT) discussion,
were eligible for analysis. Among these patients, 52 patients underwent
CCRT and 31 received RT alone after IC and we compared the two groups.
Then we further compared the IC + CCRT and IC+RT groups in IC responders
showing complete response (CR) and partial response (PR). Survival,
toxicities clinical efficacy and outcomes were analyzed. Results For IC
responders, IC+CCRT compared to IC+RT improved the locoregional
relapse-free survival (LRPFS) (median: 39.3 vs.15.13 months; P=0.033),
distant metastasis-free survival (DMFS) (median: 21.37 vs. 13.6 months;
P=0.044), PFS (median: 27.87 vs.11.37 months; P=0.048) and the overall
survival (OS) (median: 39.33 vs. 18.03 months, P=0.027). A multivariate
analysis confirmed IC+CCRT was a positive prognostic factor for LRPFS
and OS. However, for either all patients or IC non-responders, IC+CCRT
did not improve the survival compared to IC+RT. Regarding acute
toxicity, toxicities except ≥2 leucopenia were not statistically
different between the two groups. Conclusion In the IC responders, CCRT
may possess the survival benefit compared to RT alone in patients with
HPSCC. Moreover, the toxicities of two groups were comparable during the
therapy. Keywords hypopharyngeal carcinoma, induction chemotherapy,
chemoradiotherapy, radiotherapy, survival