Heterogeneity and Cancer initiation:
Cancer initiates within the habitat of the tissue and cancer cells grow
in the space of host cells52. Lately, it has been
recognized that cancer cells enter into a survival battle with the
surrounding host cells during tumorigenesis, and can kill the host cells
to make space for their growth52–57. Excitingly, in
many cases, similar competitive interactions allow host cells to
recognize the emerging cancer cells and extrude them out of the
tissue58–64. An understanding on how cancer cells
outcompete the surrounding host cells during cancer initiation may open
doors to novel targeted therapies52. Studies in the
past few years have demonstrated clonal competition and selection during
tumorigenesis in both in-vitro 65–67 andin-vivo 52–57,66–77 model systems. In
addition, signalling molecules playing mechanistic roles in
cellular-competition during tumorigenesis have been described in several
studies78–87. However, description of cell
competition remains incomplete without factoring in the inherent
cellular heterogeneity within the tissues. How does tissue heterogeneity
affect selection of mutants during cancer initiation and progression? Do
biochemical and physical heterogeneity within the tissues affect the
competitive interactions within cancer cells and host cells? Slaughter’s
concept of field cancerization88 suggest that
biochemical heterogeneity caused by the genetic and epigenetic
differences within the cells would play a crucial role in determining
growth or suppression of cancer cells. To this end, a recent study
demonstrate that genetic heterogeneity across the tissue plays an
essential role in determining survival of early neoplasms in mouse
esophageal tissue89. Another study in mice thyroid
tissue shows that intrinsic properties of thyroid follicles determined
fate of mutant cells. Follicular heterogeneity and thyroid tissue
organization dictated the fate of BRAF mutant cells90with an increased propensity of BRAF mutants to develop tumor in the
postnatal Thyroid.
Besides the genetic and mutational landscape of tissues, studies suggest
that tumour initiation may also depend on the mechanical landscape of
tissues. While mutant HRas-V12 cells are successfully extruded out from
the epithelial monolayer cultured on soft substrates, extrusion of
mutants is impaired on stiffer substrates. Furthermore, mutant cells at
the interface of soft and stiff substrates migrate to the stiff
substrate by durotaxis and evade extrusion84,
suggesting that the ECM stiffness landscape may profoundly affect
tumorigenesis. In another study, in the pancreatic tissue, tumorigenesis
was found to depend on the tissue architecture. It was observed that in
small pancreatic ducts, tumor growth was away from the duct, whereas in
large ducts tumor growth was inward towards the lumen, suggesting that
tension imbalance and tissue curvature may play a crucial role in
epithelial tumorigenesis91 . Another study show that
in stratified epithelia of skin tissue, tumor progression in the early
stages is shaped by forces exerted as a result of tissue
structure92. Cells with HRas mutation in mouse
embryonic skin produce rigid cells with high Keratin levels which are
unable to dissipate compressive forces, and hence rupture the basement
membrane and invade the underlying tissue93.
To develop a framework explaining these experimental observations
describing relevance of heterogeneity and stochasticity in cancer
initiation, application of concepts from physics such as non-linear
dynamics and critical transitions might be helpful, which will be the
focus of the next section.